***
From commanding troops in Jammu and Kashmir on the frontlines of Indian Army’s Northern Command battlegrounds during Operation VIJAY which is commonly understood as Kargil Conflict of 1999 to advising the nation’s highest security apparatus, Lieutenant General Vinod G. Khandare (PVSM, AVSM, SM) has witnessed the transformation of Indian warfare firsthand. In an exclusive conversation, he reflects on battlefield lessons that no manual can teach, the strategic evolution and logical progression to the methodology adopted in and shift behind Operation Sindoor, and why national security is now the daily responsibility of every Indian.
***
Q1. You were commanding 14 Garhwal Rifles in the Nowshera Sector when Kargil broke out in 1999. What did that summer teach you about war that no staff course or manual could?
In May 1999, I assumed command of 14 Garhwal Rifles in the Nowshera Sector of Jammu and Kashmir, and Operation Vijay started towards the end of May 1999 in the entire Northern Command.
Regarding what that summer taught us that no staff course or manual could, let me first tell you that the armed forces have a very good system of imparting training right from the day you join the academy as a young cadet. You receive a good foundation in training during the initial years. Simultaneously, as you keep growing, military training is accompanied by military education. There is a difference between training and education. Training is more applicable to equipment and its handling, fieldcraft, physical fitness, while education is related to concepts and doctrines which is at higher levels and one has to grow through many levels to understand the way victory has to be achieved at national level.
In training establishments, these concepts are taught theoretically. But the moment you come to the field, you have to apply yourself and ensure that whatever has been taught to you is customised as per the operational requirement.
Now, what do I mean by that? The moment we came to Nowshera and the operation started, we had to use our intellect to decide whether a weapon system should be used exactly as taught at the Infantry School, Mhow, or whether we should make a variation. By making a variation, we would be able to inflict more casualties. That is the first thing we learned.
Secondly, every time you do something against the enemy along the Line of Control, it gets studied. So, the second time, it will not succeed. Therefore, the next time, you must do something different. You have to surprise the enemy every time. This is the second important lesson I learned.
The next issue concerns your team of officers, JCOs and troops. There are hidden jewels. You have to discover them, and you cannot discover them merely through what is recorded in their confidential reports. You have to see how they perform in the field: their fieldcraft, IQ -EQ, bravery and presence of mind.
There is no set theoretical formula for discovering this. As a commander and as a leader, you have to operate with them in the forward areas under threat and observe how each one reacts or acts. Based on that, you have to select your teams.
The next point is how far forward you can take your logistical infrastructure so that, during critical situations, you do not have to look over your shoulder and ask, "Where is the ambulance?" The ambulance cannot come because there is no road. If there is no road, construct one. Construct a road that is not visible to the enemy. Construct shelters that are not visible to the enemy.
All these things take you to a level of practical application of what you have learned in your training and educational establishments. Set piece conventional warfare solutions do not always work.
Soldiers receive their training from regimental centres and training centres. Officers or cadets receive their first dose of training at the NDA, IMA and OTA. Thereafter, as you keep going and growing, you receive a combination of training and education during the Young Officers' Course. Soldiers receive this in their infantry battalions or regiments, whether they belong to artillery or armoured regiments.
Thereafter, you attend the Junior Command Course, which is purely military education. The practical application of the theory taught during the Junior Command Course comes when you are in the field. That is what I meant when I referred to the practical application of theoretical concepts.
There are many things that we learned, and every day was a new experience. The most important lesson was that nothing is stale. You have to keep thinking about how to outwit the enemy.
Q2. Operation Sindoor showed a very different kind of fight from Kargil Conflict of 1999, with drones, precision strikes and the information battle playing out alongside conventional forces. What was the biggest change you saw in how Bharat responds to a terror attack?
Operation Sindoor evolved from a series of incidents and resultant operations. If you recollect, PM Modi extended a hand of friendship to Pakistan by visiting Lahore to attend a family function of PM Nawaz Sharif. This did not go down well with the Pak Military, ISI and the Mulla -Maulvis. As a result at the end of 2015 and the beginning of 2016, we had an attack on Pathankot Air Base. The government tried to negotiate with Pakistan showing them evidence, but it failed.
So, we realised that we had to give a befitting reply. Even before we could do that, the attack on the Uri military base happened. India lost a number of soldiers. That was the first time the world saw an aggressive posture and attitude of aggressive retaliation, and a substantial response from India. Whether you give the credit to Prime Minister Modi or NSA Mr Ajit Doval or the Raksha Mantris Shri Manohar Parrikar or Shri Rajnath Singh, or collective credit, I leave that to you. But obviously, the apex leadership decided to go offensive, and the then Army Chief immediately got into action. General Dalbir Singh was the Army Chief at that time.
In fact, I was part of the core group. I can tell you that this is not something decided by only one man. Our political leadership never pushes the military on military issues, it decides on political objectives which is absolutely their mandate.. The core group used to meet and finalise the plan and all associated activities. That is how the surgical strikes took place at seven different locations along the 15 and 16 Corps frontage.
So, that was the first stage of evolution: from no response, whether it was the lack of a response to 26/11, attacks on various cities like Pune, Jaipur, Bengaluru, Delhi, Hyderabad or on various military targets. The military response after Uri, was a substantial one. We targeted the terrorist launch pads.
After that, what happened? Pulwama happened in 2019, a CRPF convoy moving from Jammu to Srinage was targetted by a suicide bomber. Immediately, again, the military got into action along with the NSA, the Prime Minister and the Raksha Mantri, and we decided to use something different. I told you earlier that the same trick does not succeed a second time. So, this time, the message had to be different and more stern.
The Indian Air Force was struck deep into Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, where, near Jabbar Top or Balakot, there was a terrorist training camp and a large number of terrorists had gathered. So, that was the evolution: from surgical strikes, where the Army had inflicted the damage, to a situation where the Air Force inflicted the damage. It was a perfect precision strike. We learned from that as well.
The world, and in fact, all the so-called hypocrites within India, started asking us for evidence. The armed forces expect citizens and the political fraternity, whether from the ruling party or the opposition, to believe in them and not ask such questions about evidence. The Army, Air Force and Navy had, until then, enjoyed a great deal of faith among citizens and the ruling and opposition classes. That faith was totally shattered because, during public debates on primetime television, we were being targeted and asked to provide evidence.
So, from there evolved Operation Sindoor, where we said, "Okay, we will give evidence, and we will give evidence from a third party." We could have provided satellite imagery from ISRO, but we would have been accused of doctoring the satellite images. So, satellite imagery from an American private satellite imagery company called Maxar was obtained. Its imagery is public even today, and anyone can download those images, of course, for a cost. Those images showed the kind of damage inflicted by Indian missiles and rockets on terrorist infrastructure on the night of 6–7 May, in retaliation for what had been done in Pahalgam.
Pahalgam was a dastardly act in which 26 innocent Indian civilians, tourists in Jammu and Kashmir, were killed after their religion had been ascertained. This is simply unacceptable. So, the terrorist establishments of Lashkar-e-Taiba, Hizbul Mujahideen and Jaish-e-Mohammed were targeted at their various headquarters, whether in Muridke, Bahawalpur in Pak Punjab or Muzaffarabad in Pakistan-occupied Jammu and Kashmir. In addition to these, a number of other terrorist targets were also selected.
What was different? Knowing the psyche of Pakistan and the psyche of the Indian political leadership on media, especially the opposition, it was clear that we should rely more on non-contact warfare and strike with precision deep inside. That is how we selected a couple of targets in Pak Punjab, Sind and Pakistan occupied Jammu and Kashmir. Until then, we had always restricted ourselves to Pakistan-occupied Jammu and Kashmir. This time, the targets selected were deeper and even across the International Border.
Having done that, another precaution was taken: the timing of the attacks was chosen to ensure that civilians were not hurt. No mosque was selected as a target during namaz time. The attacks took place in the dead of the night, at 0100 or 0102 hours, when no namaz was being offered. If there was anybody inside these terrorist establishments, he deserved to be eliminated because he was himself a terrorist. That was the logic behind the choice of targets and the timing of the attacks.
Thereafter, when we received confirmed intelligence through our intelligence sources that Pakistan was planning retaliation of immense magnitude, the Indian Air Force, the Army, Indian Navy and everyone else quickly went in for integrated precision strikes on the night of 9–10 May against Pakistan Air Force bases, radar sites, communication centres and command posts. These were all legitimate military targets.
The damage was again captured accurately by Maxar. So, what exactly are we looking at in the evolution of retaliation? Escalation control. We did not want to get into a senseless, protracted war like the one happening between Ukraine and Russia. Zelensky has ruined his country based on the instigation of European leaders and President Trump of the USA. We were very clear that we would select targets that mattered, strike those targets and prevent Pakistan from retaliating. Once we selected these targets and, in a way, paralysed Pakistan's response, the escalation ladder was under our control.
How was it controlled? The Pakistani DGMO, a Major General-rank officer, rang up the Indian DGMO, a Lieutenant General-rank officer, and said, "Sir, you have damaged enough. Why don't we stop?" That was when everything stopped.
We had decided on military targets based on the political aim, and that aim had been achieved. In the military, whenever you plan an operation, it is based on clear-cut military aims and objectives. Once those are achieved, there is nothing more that you can do unless the political aim changes. The political aim did not change. We wanted to teach them a lesson, we taught them a lesson, and we stopped.
In the bargain, what did we achieve? Our economy did not suffer the way the Ukrainian economy is suffering. Our goal of achieving Viksit Bharat by 2047, and I want to add Surakshit Bharat, continues on its trajectory without being shaken.
So, I think we need to be very clear that a terrorist attack is responded to by targeting terrorist infrastructure, and we must be ready to retaliate in case Pakistan responds, as it did. It targeted our civilians; we did not. The moment Pakistan targeted our civilians with drones and rockets in the forward areas, whether in Uri, Poonch, Rajouri or Barmer, we immediately went in for deep strikes.
These deep strikes were spread across the entire frontage, as far North as Skardu in Gilgit Baltistan and as far South as Bholari in Sind province. Among the important targets was Nur Khan Air Base, the biggest command post of the Pakistan Army and Air Force. Incidentally, Nur Khan Air Base is one of the air bases capable of launching aircraft for a nuclear strike. So, even that option was taken away from Pakistan.
I think that sums up everything about Operation Sindoor, although Operation Sindoor continues. Phase 1 was a military strike. Phase 2, which is ongoing, goes beyond military capabilities and extends into other domains of comprehensive national power and security. These include water security, energy security, economic measures and diplomatic initiatives to get Pakistan back onto the FATF list, as well as isolating Pakistan in terms of trade.
There are many such domains being used. The ongoing tightening of Indian initiatives and the stopping of trade have resulted in massive price rises in Pakistan for items of daily use. Through the kind of initiative India has taken with Europe, Pakistan's textile industry will be taken off the GSP plus list by Europe, making its products costlier. The suspension of the Indus Waters Treaty and the offer India has made to Kabul to finance its Kabul Dam will also affect agricultural production in Pakistan. You will find it going down and down. So, this is non-contact warfare.
In modern warfare, everything is not decided by military impact alone. The impact will not last if you undertake only one military action. You have to do much more. All citizens have to do their bit because it is not only the military that is fighting Pakistan; it is each and every citizen who is fighting Pakistan and every enemy of Bharat .
Q3. You often speak of comprehensive national power. In simple terms, what does it mean for an ordinary citizen, and why is a strong army alone no longer enough to keep Bharat secure?
I always emphasise comprehensive national power and comprehensive national security. When you start looking at what a common citizen is supposed to do, every citizen is a weapon of the entire nation.
In China, there is a law under which every citizen is supposed to inform the PLA or the CPC if they notice something that could be of use to China in enhancing its comprehensive national power or where comprehensive national security is threatened. These citizens could be residing in China or could be tourists visiting foreign lands, they could be part of the diaspora, studying abroad or trading abroad. What does this mean? If nearly 1.4 billion people in China are assets of the Chinese Communist Party or the PLA, imagine the level, frequency and quality of intelligence available to China’s planners at the apex level. A similar example exists in Israel. There is a system of conscription under which every male and female has to serve for prescribed periods in the Israel Defense Forces. What does this mean? When these young people leave the IDF, if they do not want to continue or are not found suitable to continue, they enter the civilian stream. What do they do? They add to the comprehensive national power because they have just experienced the deficiencies or scope of improvement in the IDF, and they join startups or start their own ventures. Wherever they are, they continuously look out for anything that could threaten Israel's national security.
During one of my visits to Israel, I had to travel from Tel Aviv to Eilat. Eilat is a coastal city right at the southern end of Israel. We hired a taxi. Incidentally, the taxi driver was of Indian origin, from Shivaji Park in Mumbai. He became quite friendly, but he kept his guard up throughout. He wanted to extract as much as he could and give as little as he could. This is called strategic wisdom.
Indian citizens and prominent Indians should not be giving away information about what India is doing, what India has achieved or what India's deficiencies are. That is an expectation of the nation.
Let me give you another example involving the same driver, whose name was Yossi. While we were travelling through the Negev Desert, which is a vast expanse, he was continually looking left and right. I noticed this and asked him, "Yossi, what are you looking for?" He said, "Sir, as a citizen, I have to be vigilant, and in case I find something suspicious, I must immediately report it."
So, I asked him, "Do you know whom you have to report it to?" He immediately showed me a list of numbers pasted on the sunshade of the car. If he saw a particular kind of threat, he had to dial the relevant number. This means that a country under existential threat, surrounded by enemies or potential enemies, has built processes, procedures and attitudes that involve every citizen in the protection of the country.
Let me go a bit further. Health is extremely important for a nation. You have a huge youth bulge. But if your youth bulge is unhealthy because young people consume fast food, use medicines right from childhood and are not physically active, what good is this human resource asset if their health is poor?
If you are being lured into a lifestyle by the West, you have to get out of it. That is a comprehensive national power when I talk about health. Whether it is the insurance company lobby, the pharmaceutical industry or hospitals, you have to be very clear that you need a healthy population. In other countries, people are outside exercising early in the morning. Are we seeing that in India? I think we need a wake-up call on that.
The next aspect is the skills of human resources. Are we sure that our youth bulge is skilled? The recent agitation at Jantar Mantar showed that neither are people adequately skilled, had hardly any knowledge except some gossip based loose information nor is their attitude aligned with the nation. They are more inclined towards damaging the existing structure and the way the nation functions, targeting the leadership and discouraging good people from joining politics or law enforcement agencies.
It is simple. You are funded from abroad. You organise a protest. You target sincere leadership, and then good people who want to join the political hierarchy say, "Oh, this is too bad. My family reputation will get tarnished. I am not coming into politics." That is something we must be careful about. The same concerns are relevant to police forces.
The other aspect of skills is that if you are only looking for government jobs which are very limited, I think we are moving on the wrong trajectory. Education and skills should ensure that you create your own ventures and generate jobs rather than look for a job yourself. This is an old mentality in which everyone wanted a government job because, once you got into one, nobody questioned you. You had a pension and a settled life. I think the time has come when degrees will not matter as much as skills. Comprehensive national power is important in this context.
Let me come to one more important issue: environmental security. Please go on Google and see what China is doing towards modifying or geo-engineering the environment. There is a project that China has been working on to increase rainfall in the Tibetan Plateau. Now, people will ask why. The dam being built on the Tsangpo River in the middle of nowhere cannot be only for flooding India. Hydroelectricity is to be used in Tibet to make it green. The Han population, which generally resides only in the East, has to be pushed towards the West. For that, they need roads, which they have built; railways, which they have built and continue to build; and airports. They need electricity, water and cultivation, for which water is essential. These are strategic decisions, and this is how comprehensive national power will increase.
But in our case, our environment is being targeted. There is another project that China is undertaking, called the Sky River Project. Please go on Google; you will find enough material on it. It concerns how to divert moisture from the atmosphere to a place of your choice, which would be Tibet. Where does this moisture come from? Obviously, the monsoons operating over Indian soil have to be targeted.
If these are environmental projects about which no political party or leader talks, and students and professors in colleges and universities are absolutely ill-informed, how do you think we will become a developed power by 2047? I think we need a major shift in our focus and attitude.
Comprehensive national power and comprehensive national security go hand in hand. Unless you have comprehensive national power, you cannot have the best security. And unless you have comprehensive national security, you will never grow in comprehensive national power, there has to be an environment of assured protection. There are many other examples that can be given, but for want of time, I will not be able to cover them.
I want to cover a few more domains of comprehensive national power and security. The first is the economy.
Putting tariffs on our products, diverting our trade or discouraging our trade are additional ways of ensuring that India does not grow and does not become a competitor to existing global powers.
Henry Kissinger had insisted on propping up China to defeat the erstwhile USSR, and they succeeded in doing so. The only thing the USA did not realise was that it was dealing with a wise Oriental country that grew stronger. After a particular period, China became a threat to the USA. American planners have now realised this and openly say that they will not make the same mistake again. Therefore, they want to stymie India's growth. We have to be very clear that we are on our own when it comes to economic prosperity.
So, what should a citizen do? Stop wastage. Stop recurring expenditure. If you pollute a river and then spend money to clean it, you are wasting resources. If you pollute the atmosphere and create sick people, you are again wasting resources. If you create riots, the same money that could have been used for something better gets diverted to repair and replace damaged assets. Your economy gets stuck in a cycle that does not help it move forward.
The next aspect is food security or agricultural security. Although these are two different things, let me cover them together. Genetically modified crops, or crops whose saplings are produced in laboratories, are dragging us towards a particular system of agriculture that takes us away from traditional agriculture, which depended on conventional seeds and produced healthy food. America is pressurising India to buy its genetically modified products, and they have a very harmful effect on the soil, animals and human beings.
So, here again, strategic autonomy in foreign policy is helping India because we are not bowing down to pressure and are not blindly signing on the dotted line for a trade agreement.
What else can I tell you about economic security or economic power? Corruption. Corruption exists at different levels, and I do not necessarily want to say that it is confined to any particular level. It is at the ground level, committed by the common man. It is at the middle level, committed by the babus. Traders indulge in corruption by avoiding taxes. It also exists at higher levels. Ex PM Rajiv Gandhi publicly stated that only 15 paise worth out of a Rupee reaches its destined place or person due to intense corruption. So, at all levels, a patriotic Indian should wake up and recognise that corruption is ruining the country's growth, whether economically or ethically. We have to be very clear about that.
There are many other aspects of comprehensive economic power. One of them is self-sufficiency and self-reliance. If we continue to depend on imports, our hard-earned foreign exchange reserves, which generally come from the remittances of Indians working hard abroad, will get wasted.
To a large extent, the country has reduced wastage through government efforts. Take locomotives, for example. More than 90 per cent of locomotives have shifted to electricity. Diesel wastage and expenditure have therefore reduced. Electric vehicles are being encouraged.
The crisis in the Strait of Hormuz has shown the entire world, whether China, India or Europe, that everyone is affected by the energy crisis. Prices have gone up. So, we have to create more renewable energy options and build more strategic petroleum reserves because petroleum cannot be ruled out entirely. Petroleum and its by-products have considerable utility in Indian agriculture and industry. We will have to look at renewable and alternative options, including nuclear small modular reactors.
Imagine the cost of diesel when an entire fuel tanker has to travel to the Andaman and Nicobar Islands for electricity generation. Instead, if we can position small modular nuclear reactors, whether on remote islands or in remote mountains, imagine the national savings that would accrue.
Going ahead, what more do I want to talk about? Our exports. We have a very good internal market, but we need to increase our exports because they bring in foreign exchange. The more foreign exchange or gold we acquire, the stronger our currency becomes. Here, the issues of smuggling and the hoarding of currency, driven by corruption, also need attention. We saw demonetisation in 2016 because the same money was being channelled towards terrorism.
In addition to corruption, we have to control terrorism. Terrorism does not come only from across the border. There are supporters within the country as well. Operation Sindoor brought about an awareness or wake-up call that there were so many illegal migrants in border States like Jammu and Kashmir. How did they come? Obviously, there was some connivance, whether by the authorities or the population. They need to be sent back. These people are raising families and taking full advantage of welfare schemes for which an honest taxpayer pays, while also creating national security threats. These are the sleeper cells dangerous for the nation.
Internal cohesion and internal security have to be strengthened. This cannot happen only during a crisis; it is a daily affair. The best sources of governance and security are police stations. If corruption in a police station reduces, security will improve. If the beat policeman does his job sincerely, security will improve. If political leaders at the ground level allow the police to function and do not interfere in their work, the situation will improve.
So, what exactly am I saying? Law and order and governance have to reach a new level of effectiveness and efficiency. Otherwise, we will continue to be targeted by rogue elements within the country because of our lapses in governance, law and order.
Technological sovereignty: What does technological sovereignty mean? We should not be looking towards Western countries to provide us with the best possible aeronautical engines or the best possible aircraft. Now, having completed nearly eight decades of independence, we should look at ourselves and ask why we are still unable to manufacture engines.
The largest number of engineers are educated in India. So, why is research and development such a low priority? Every parent would want their child to become a doctor, engineer or MBA, enter the corporate world or become a lawyer or become a bureaucrat because that is where money is earned quickly. But research and development is a national priority, and the country needs to focus on it very quickly.
You go to Tel Aviv Airport, and as you enter the airport after getting off the aircraft and the bus, you will find the names of Nobel Prize winners on both sides of the walkway. You can count what we have in India: nothing. So, we need to encourage a culture and attitude in which research and development are prioritised and the scientific community is looked after. Their economic interests and aspirations need to be looked at.
I also want to talk about educational security. The time has come for us to review the educational prospectus, curriculum and methodology of teaching. Look at different countries. They have adopted methods that allow the human brain to reach a stage where people can undertake independent analysis.
In India, we have multiple-choice questions. Does that increase analytical or assessment capability? It does not. I think we need to look much further and honour only the best. Train them hard and choose the best. Countries like Singapore choose the best human resource as teachers for their educational institutions. Their social and economic status is distinctly better than many other professions in Singapore. There are many issues related to education which need to be evaluated for their efficacy.
One important aspect is history. If your history has been tampered with and, for eight decades, you have not been able to correct it, it is only we who have to blame ourselves. If you are always portrayed as a victim or a loser, how will the new generations develop pride in themselves?
I think we need to revisit this and give it top priority to ensure that self-confidence, dignity and self-esteem are enhanced. We are not a country of losers; we have won many battles. India, as a landmass and even as a maritime power, has had many heroes. Why are we only eulogising Western warriors, commanders, admirals and strategists? It is because we have lost faith in what our ancestors did. I think we need to revisit that very quickly.
A lot of changes are coming up, but what is being discussed in the media is, again, quite disgusting and more towards admiration of our invaders and colonisers.
Information warfare: We need laws. Anyone who violates these laws or acts contrary to the national interest needs to be investigated and booked. This current situation, where anyone can say anything against anybody, ultimately harming the nation, needs to be stopped very quickly.
Q4. Space, cyber and counter-drone systems now come up in almost every strategic discussion. Where do you think Bharat is genuinely strong, and where must we move faster?
Space, cyber, drones and counter-drone systems are domains of the new era.
We have to look at space as a domain that will give us surveillance over our entire area of responsibility and over our potential and identified enemies as well. There can be no shortcut. Space domain is a profession that is not very popular, except in southern India. I think our engineers and graduates need to give more attention to space as a domain. As of now, most of the time, only a select few people are looking at space, and it isgenerally the armed forces that are looking at space.
Space has implications for both the civil and military domains. It is a dual-use technology. So, we really need to bring our best human resources into this field and develop our space capabilities. We have very good human resources. You have heard of youngsters who have started their own startups, whether Agnikul, Skyroot, Dhruva Space, Galaxeye, Pixel or others. They have worked hard, launched satellites and put them into space, they have done much more than only making and launching satellites. We are very proud of them, and we need to encourage them further. There are bigger industry partners in the Space domain which need to be encouraged like Anant Technologies and some more.
The problem arises in our processes. Startups need money. I think our banking system has to link up with them. They need money, and you can give them loans based on their intellectual property. But to understand their IP, bank officials have to be trained themselves. As of now, they only talk about commerce. In the government machinery, the evil of L1 needs to go at the earliest.
We need to work on three principles. The first is security. If there are objectionable sources of component supply, then, during the initial security check itself, these products and companies need to be disqualified.
The second is technological superiority. If there is competition in terms of technological superiority, the best and the second-best should both be considered. The final criterion should then be price.
Our requirement is massive. We need thousands of satellites. Those thousands of satellites can be procured only if we allow L1, L2 and L3 bidders to provide what we need at the cost of L1. There is nothing wrong with that. But by then, you would have completed the entire process of security and technological assessment before reaching L1 and conducting negotiations.
Now, when you come to space warfare, launching a rocket and putting a satellite into space are not everything. There has to be communication, and there has to be cyber resilience. In addition, India also has to address its deficiency in rare earths.
There are a number of asteroids and planets that contain rare earths. I think that, beyond merely looking at the success of a rocket reaching a planet, we need to start developing, very quickly, the capability to extract rare earths from these asteroids or planets and bring them back. We should also look at zero-gravity manufacturing in space, which will definitely be cheaper. I think we need to diversify beyond merely launching rockets and putting satellites in orbit. That is another thing that will improve our comprehensive national power.
Coming to cyber, we have excellent human resources in this field, but we are still unable to match the kind of skills that Estonia, China and others possess. I think we need a major push, and that push cannot depend only on what foreign countries have to offer. They will never give you the best. We need our own awareness of cyber hygiene, cyber experts and ethical hackers to do much more. Our cyber experts have done a lot and achieved a great deal, but there is still considerable ground to cover. A lot happens on the dark net.
Law enforcement agencies and intelligence personnel work extensively on the dark net. We need to empower citizens. We need to put cyber warriors in place and provide them with legal protection. China has done a lot to create its own cyber warriors. Just one indication from the government, and they all crack down on and target a particular country or company and bring down its cyber defences.
So, in cyber, the defence mechanism has to be strong. At the same time, we have to create many cyber warriors, ethical cyber warriors, and ensure that they deliver when required in national interest.
Drones and counter-drones are low-cost options in modern warfare. Israel's Iron Dome suffered a major problem when drones and cheap projectiles were launched on 7 October, and so much chaos took place in Israel. That is something we need to learn from. We also need to learn from the Russia-Ukraine war, where drones were smuggled deep into Russia and used to target its strategic bombers. This shows the fertile minds at work. The range or distance to be covered by drones may be limited, but they can be pushed in depth areas through various ways. It is not necessary that everything has to be carried on an aircraft or a missile. There are different ways of smuggling them inside.
Electronic warfare is another vital aspect. You can see what Israel did to the Hezbollah leadership by targeting their pagers. Hezbollah leadership had ensured that smartphones would not be used, to prevent their location discovery. They were relying on pagers, and that is what Israel targeted. It was a precision strike with a long period of silent preparation by MOSSAD, the famous Israeli intelligence agency. Here it is evident that Intelligence agencies also need a deep knowledge of technology, foresight for practical application and smart decision making with years of patience without invoking audit objections.
Such fertile ideas have to emerge from the creativity developed in the Indian mind. Multiple-choice questions never generate creativity.
Drones and counter-drones are low-cost options that can deliver a lethal blow wherever they are launched from. The Indian system has to develop an excellent counter-drone system all along the border, and that can be done only by the government. State Police, BSF, SSB, Assam Rifles, ITBP, Coast Guard and the Indian Armed Forces have to get equipped with their terrain and threat specific counter drone solutions of equipment, processes, human resources and coordination mechanisms. Surveillance, target detection, identification of friend and foe, timely targeting and debris forensics has to be looked at as one solution along all borders and the hinterland.
Key economic and logistical installations, whether refineries or industrial hubs, definitely need customised counter-drone capabilities. These can then all be linked to provide gap-free coverage through counter-drone capabilities.
There is a lot of work to be done, and India needs to race ahead. For that, more money is required. India can afford to divert more money because the results are beneficial to the economy as well. Drones and counter-drones, space capabilities and cyber capabilities all yield results for the economy. So, we should not be shy of investing money, giving tax holidays to startups and providing land at cheaper rates for manufacturing facilities.
At the same time, audits must be very strict but corruption and interference free. We should not allow people to fool us by bringing in products from countries that provide them cheaply, cutting and pasting components, assembling them here and passing them off as their own products. Ultimately, during a crisis, such pirated inventory will not work. This is extremely important for those who place purchase orders. Quality assurance of the items ordered and delivered is the responsibility of the person signing the purchase order. I think that is another important aspect of technology.
Communication security is another issue. Look at how dependent we are on the internet. WhatsApp and all our data are going abroad to the USA and its data centres. Facebook data is also going abroad. In addition, plenty of data that is neither on WhatsApp nor on Facebook is also going abroad due lack of sensitivity, accountability and control mechanisms.
Poor cyber hygiene is leading to data losses, voluntarily or involuntarily. We often say that data is gold, data is oil and data is wealth. But when it comes to protecting our data, we are not doing enough. Here again, many specialists have to be employed or contracted by the government to ensure that data is preserved. If data is not preserved, we are giving away all our secrets.
So, in addition to drone and counter-drone capabilities, I have added one more important aspect: data security.
Q5. You have served in uniform, in intelligence, in the National Security Council Secretariat and the Ministry of Defence, and now sit on a corporate board. What would you tell a young Indian who wants to serve the nation but isn't sure the armed forces are their path?
Intelligence gathering and intelligence sharing are not merely the responsibilities of intelligence agencies. Every individual citizen and every well-meaning person should always be on the lookout for anything that can harm the nation. Lapses and offences fall in the category of a challenge to internal cohesion, the infiltration of undesirable elements or the manipulation of information, because information warfare is the latest threat.
Never believe something simply because it comes to you easily. Anything being given free should be viewed with suspicion. Get it assessed. There are experts who do this.
If you remain vigilant with your eyes and your finger on the pulse of cyber, information security, and for curbing corruption the country will remain stable. But the moment you start believing all the nonsense that comes to you so easily, and you give in to the fastest-finger syndrome of forwarding it immediately to others, look at the kind of damage that happens. If we leave every responsibility to the Government, the nation will fail under pressure.
Take a hypothetical example. If somebody wants to create chaos in India and hacks into our railway reservation system across the country, at every railway station, and allots the same berth to a number of people, there will be total turbulence and trauma at all the railway stations. That is exactly what our enemies want. Riots, strikes, agitations and damages to property are anti national agendas. Foreign investments reduce in such nations.
If you tarnish the image of good senior leadership, you have to look at the people who are doing it. They may be paid from abroad, or from vested groups from within the nation itself, they may not be good citizens. They discourage good citizens from becoming senior leaders because nobody wants to lose their mental peace or their family's reputation. As a result, good people will not come forward.
So, we have to look at citizens as assets and not limitations. We often think that having a huge population has become a limitation. No, that is not correct.
Everyone cannot join the armed forces, but we will need trained people. Why do I say that? Look at Russia and Ukraine and the kind of losses they have suffered. Russia has had to borrow 30,000 soldiers from North Korea. Why? Because, given the number of injured personnel and fatal casualties, it is unable to meet the requirement for soldiers on the front line. So, it has borrowed soldiers from North Korea. This is not a very good indication.
In the case of India, what is our reservist policy or the availability of a reservist pool? It is limited. Once a person leaves the Army or the police, the age factor makes him less capable of continuing in active service. The NCC syllabus or curriculum today does not meet the requirement of filling the void that the armed forces would face.
It is an unspoken rule that, during the initial phase of the ferocity of an operation, the best officers and the best soldiers are killed. How do you fill that gap? You need a reservist policy. You need trained reservists. They need to undergo regular refresher training, and this should be taken as a positive aspect.
A reservist requirement is not limited to personnel; it also applies to equipment. A large amount of equipment gets damaged, whether tanks, guns, rifles, aircraft or ships. What is our manufacturing capability to fill this void? We need to speed up.
The culture of our DPSUs and PSUs has to improve. They must move from being welfare- and job-oriented establishments to strategic establishments. Motivated management and equally motivated workers are needed. We need to learn from Japan, Singapore, South Korea and Israel about work efficiency, they are all democracies. The Indian government did well to disband the Ordnance Factory Board and convert the 41 ordnance factories into seven DPSUs. But these also need to be audited. In addition, the existing PSUs under every ministry have to be audited and improved.
The current approach, which depends more on socialism and the welfare of workers, needs to change. Workers' welfare, subject to performance audits, should be the way forward. We have to compete with world powers. We must become globally competitive based on capability not on someone's mercy.
Competition between the public and private sectors has to be encouraged. Corruption also has to be reduced.
So, every citizen who is not in uniform is still a combatant, but in civvies rather than in uniform. Everyone has to feel that he or she must do much more than what is being done at present or what has been done in the past. This thought will build India for the near future as per the national vision.
We have to bring in a lot of change in our attitude, starting right from schools and families. The first step is to bring about a change in the attitude of teachers and the administrative setup in schools and colleges. Only then will we get nationalist output from our educational institutions. Families must groom children to be good contributing citizens rather than the complaining variety. There are many good examples in the world to emulate and many bad habits to discard for our common national good.
***
Seema Sanghosh English | November 2026

A lucid and uncluttered view by Gen Khandare, it is always a privilege to listen/ read his vision on National Security
ReplyDelete