By Brig Sansar Verma
***
Introduction
Starlink, a constellation of Low Earth Orbit (LEO) satellites developed by SpaceX, is the world’s largest satellite system, with over 7,000 satellites in orbit, providing high-speed broadband globally. For India, a nation of 145 crore people with vast remote areas, a 7,500 km coastline and 15,000 km of contested borders, satellite broadband is not a luxury but a strategic necessity. India granted Starlink a GMPCS licence and IN-SPACe authorisation in June 2025, and the company has established 20 gateway earth stations with hundreds of antennas. Yet, as of October 2026, commercial launch remains pending due to the lack of MHA security clearance and spectrum assignment.
Why India Needs Starlink
Presently, we have major shortcomings in the existing system, both for civil and military purposes.
Firstly, the lack of roads. Our existing system relies on ground-based fibre and towers. India has 6.5 lakh villages, of which about 40,000 still do not have mobile connectivity, and about 2.5 lakh villages have no fibre. In regions like Ladakh, Arunachal, Siachen, Bastar and the Andaman Islands, laying fibre costs Rs 50 lakh per km. In mountainous regions, towers require roads, power and diesel. On the other hand, Starlink needs only an open sky, with no road or power grid.
Secondly, speed and latency are problems. ISRO-GSAT operates from a geostationary orbit (GEO) at 36,000 km, with a latency of 600 ms; hence, video calls and drone control are impossible, and telemedicine fails. Also, speeds are only 2–10 Mbps, and the terminal costs Rs 5 lakh. On the other hand, Starlink operates in LEO at 550 km, with a latency of 25 ms (comparable to Delhi fibre), a speed of 200 Mbps and a terminal costing Rs 30,000, making it 30 times better.
Thirdly, communication becomes a problem during war and disasters, as fibre and towers become the first casualties. During the Galwan conflict in 2020, fibre was sabotaged, resulting in a communication blackout. During the Kerala floods of 2018, 2,000 towers were down for 10 days. Starlink works on battery power and is independent of terrestrial infrastructure; hence, Army forward posts, Navy ships and BSF boats will continue to remain connected. Likewise, Starlink also ensured that the Ukrainian Army could continue its communication when Russia destroyed its towers.
Fourthly, presently, Jio and Airtel cannot provide communication to moving platforms such as fishing boats 100 km out at sea, Indian Navy destroyers in the IOR, trains in Konkan or aircraft over the North East. Starlink, however, continues to work in moving vehicles, ships and aircraft, as was demonstrated in Ukraine.
Fifthly, without assured communication, a fisherman may lose his life, a soldier may lose his post, and a child in a remote area may lose future opportunities due to the lack of online classes. The cost of our present system of providing universal fibre connectivity to every hamlet is very high, whereas Starlink can connect them in three months, with 20 gateways already built.
Overall, therefore, Starlink has an edge over existing communication systems in India. GEO systems (ISRO-GSAT and Viasat) have 30 times higher latency (25 ms versus 600 ms), 20 times lower speed and larger dishes compared to Starlink’s small, pizza-box-sized terminal. Against its LEO competitor OneWeb, Starlink has seven times more satellites, vertically integrated launch capabilities (SpaceX Falcon 9 is cheaper) and higher throughput. Compared to terrestrial 5G, Starlink is independent of the power grid and fibre cuts, making it resilient during wars, floods and earthquakes.
Characteristics of Starlink
The key characteristics of Starlink are its LEO satellites at an altitude of 550 km, Ku and Ka bands, inter-satellite laser links (which eliminate the need to route traffic through a gateway for global coverage), phased-array user terminals that automatically track satellites, and mass production at low cost. One satellite covers a 1,000 km radius, revisits every few minutes, and the constellation ensures continuous coverage. Direct-to-Cell (Gen2) now allows normal mobile handsets to connect without a ground terminal, a capability tested in the USA in 2026.
Implications for India
Military: Starlink provides India with real-time video from LAC posts, drone swarm control and secure communications for forward units where fibre is sabotaged. The BSF, Coast Guard and Navy gain broadband connectivity at sea.
Governance: Areas such as e-Sanjeevani healthcare, e-education, DBT, weather advisories for fishermen and disaster response during Himalayan cloudbursts will be adequately supported by Starlink.
Strategic Autonomy in the IOR: Starlink will provide connectivity to Indian fishermen and islands, thereby effectively countering Chinese influence in the region.
Kill-Switch Risk: SpaceX unilaterally restricted Starlink for Ukraine’s attack on the Russian Black Sea Fleet in 2023. A similar risk could arise during an India-Pakistan war if the US exerts pressure.
Security Bypass: Encrypted traffic via foreign satellites may bypass Indian lawful interception. It could also potentially be used by terrorists, Naxals and drug smugglers.
Dependency: India would become completely reliant on a US private company for critical communication, which is also against the spirit of Atmanirbharta. On the other hand, Starlink may create orbital congestion and light pollution, affecting ISRO astronomy missions.
Economic Angle: Satellite broadband in India is projected to reach $1.9 billion by 2030. Starlink, in partnership with Jio and Airtel as distribution partners, can create 10,000 direct jobs in gateway maintenance. However, cheap satellite connectivity could render the Rs 5 lakh crore investment made by telecom companies in 5G unviable in rural areas; a level playing field is therefore needed. Fishing, mining and logistics sectors will see a productivity jump, as one connected fishing boat can save Rs 50,000 per trip in diesel by locating fish through satellite data.
Effects on the Make-in-India Mission: Starlink currently imports terminals from the USA. The DoT should insist on phased manufacturing: at least 30% Make-in-India content within two years and 100% within five years, as with the telecom PLI. ISRO’s NSIL and private players such as Astrome and Dhruva Space can learn mass production and provide an Indian alternative through Project ISRO-Anvesha LEO. If we only become consumers, we lose our strategic edge. However, if we co-produce and insist on Indian gateway software, we gain technology and data security.
Effects and Counter-Effects Concerning China and Pakistan: China is actively developing its own massive LEO satellite constellations, such as the “G60 Starlink” and “Guowang” networks, to counter US space dominance. If India relies completely on a Western, US-based constellation like Starlink, it risks entering a secondary technological dependency. Furthermore, strict terminal tracking is vital; unauthorised Starlink terminals operating along the Line of Actual Control could result in sensitive military data being leaked or intercepted externally.
Indian security forces are also highly sensitive to the threat of satellite terminals being smuggled across borders. Pakistan has no LEO constellation and depends on Chinese BeiDou and the Chinese LEO project GuoWang (13,000 planned satellites). Non-state actors or terrorist outfits operating in rugged terrain could bypass local cellular blackouts using unauthorised satellite dishes to coordinate cross-border infiltration. This is why India demands strict “Terminal Accountability”, ensuring that every single device active within Indian borders is physically identifiable and geo-fenced.
Conditions Imposed by the Indian Government on All Players
The Indian Government has imposed several conditions, not only on Starlink but also on all three players: Starlink, Jio-Satcom and OneWeb.
Firstly, all Indian user data must pass through Gateway Earth Stations built inside India. There will be no routing abroad and no decryption or mirroring outside India. Starlink claims that it has already built 20 sites.
Secondly, no player will be permitted to use inter-satellite laser links to bypass Indian gateways. They must prove that traffic remains within India and is monitored here.
Thirdly, lawful interception will be mandatory, including real-time monitoring, location tracking, the ability to block websites or users, and the ability to shut down services in specific areas during emergencies or hostilities. There will also be intensive monitoring in a special 5 km border zone and a 200-nautical-mile maritime zone.
Fourthly, a minimum of 20% of the ground segment—including gateways, antennas and terminals—must be manufactured in India within five years, including support for NavIC.
In addition, licences, spectrum allocation and FDI will require Government approval.
Reasons for the Delay in Starlink’s Launch in India
The first reason is the final approval from the MHA, following reports of unauthorised Starlink use during the Iran war, concerns about the loss of lawful interception and the smuggling of terminals into Kashmir and Naxal-affected areas.
Actual frequency allotment is also pending due to spectrum assignment. The Government is insisting that Indian user data, routing and kill-switch capabilities remain within India through Indian gateways only.
In addition, there is a problem of commercial viability, as the expected cost is Rs 30,000 for the kit and an additional Rs 3,000–4,000 per month, which is beyond the reach of the rural poor without USOF subsidies.
Conclusion
Starlink is not merely an internet service; it is strategic infrastructure, much like the Suez Canal was for sea power. India cannot afford to miss the LEO revolution, nor can it afford blind adoption.
The right model is to permit Starlink, but with Indian controls: data localisation, Indian ground stations, MHA-approved lawful interception, Army geo-fencing, a Make-in-India roadmap, and parallel development of an indigenous LEO constellation by ISRO and the private sector for long-term interests.
It is suggested that we use Starlink for the next 10 years as a bridge and build Bharatlink for the next 50 years. India should use Starlink not as a competitor to Jio/Airtel fibre, but as backhaul for Army border posts, Navy ships, the Leh-Ladakh region, the North East and the Andaman Islands, as well as for disaster recovery, so that when a mobile tower goes down, satellite communication remains available.
If we do this, we will achieve connectivity while maintaining security and preventing monopolies. We must, therefore, physically verify compliance, ensure a Make-in-India process and control prices. The Government must test all these factors quickly and then allow Starlink.
Seema Sanghosh English | November 2026

No comments:
Post a Comment